The Power of Incentives
Suggestion Program Saves $22 Million in 18 Months
HR Magazine: Sept, 2003
by Donna Oldenburg
Employers that think they can't afford incentive and recognition
programs in a tough economy may be disillusioned. When West Valley
Nuclear Services chose to use these powerful business tools the
suggestions flew and the bottom line soared.
By investing $20,000 in an employee suggestion program West Valley
Nuclear Services'West Valley, N.Y. Waste Minimization and Pollution
Prevention program realized more than $2.2 million in cost avoidances in
an 18-month period. [paragraph] West Valley Nuclear Services manages and
operates the West Valley Demonstration project, an environmental cleanup
operation within the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE). Cathy Atkinson,
chair of the program, and her team developed the employee suggestion
program in response to stringent new DOE guidelines regarding energy
savings and procurement, as well as the reduction of all types of waste
streams (radioactive, hazardous, industrial and sanitary). [paragraph]
Although the company already had a Waste Minimization and Pollution
Prevention Program (Wmin/P2) in place, employee participation was
limited and customers did not view the program as effective. In
addition, tracking the various initiatives and activities was difficult
because many employee efforts were not being captured in company
reports. With the new guidelines for energy savings and procurement in
effect, Atkinson knew it was time to get more aggressive about how
things were done
"We wanted to find a way to track how we were meeting our goals,"
Atkinson says. "We also wanted to save money, recognize employees for
the good things they were doing, encourage them to do more, and have
documentation to prove that we were doing all of these things to meet
our goals."
The solution was an incentive program developed in conjunction with The
Bill Sims Co., a Columbia, S.C.-based incentive and recognition company.
"Having an incentive program to reach our goals was a new concept," she
says. "The DOE had just recently mandated new goals that were rather
aggressive. Both the company's and program's performance and budget was
dependent on reaching these target goals so we knew we had to 'get out
of the box' to hit our target. We chose a program that would allow us to
align our goals, track our progress, make it easy for employees to use
and recognize their efforts, and give us a return on investment."
With federal and state budget cuts looming, Atkinson and her team "knew
the company had to prove itself or risk the loss of much needed funding.
More than 800 employees from engineers to cafeteria workers were
targeted with the program.
"Because the goals and criteria were clearly stated and provided on
every suggestion form, employees knew what expected of them and could
put their efforts in the areas where they had direct knowledge,"
Atkinson explains. "They also knew up front what they could expect from
their efforts."
To ensure employees received timely feedback, the Waste Min/P2 team
reviewed the suggestions every two weeks. This two-week response time
kept employees motivated, as well as focused on implementing suggestions
that had been accepted.
Implemented suggestions earned employees "Star Bucks" tickets, which
they could then redeem for awards from a special gift catalog. A
quarterly drawing for larger prizes, such as a cruise, was also held.
Awards were shipped directly to employees' homes in order to encourage
family excitement about the program.
In the 18 months that Atkinson headed up the program, West Valley
Nuclear Services received 183 suggestions; 63 of which were actually
implemented.
According to Atkinson, the program resulted in more than $2.2 million in
cost savings and avoidances, and the company finally was able to
document what was being done to reach goals, as well justify the
program's value. In addition, West Valley's customer, the Department of
Energy, gave the company high ratings for developing such an innovative
and cost-effective program. At the national level, the program also was
recognized in the DOE Pollution Prevention newsletter. But the best
part, stresses Atkinson, was the program's return on investment.
"We paid pennies on the dollar. If you're looking for a way to save
money, get your employees to help you do that. They know the waste in
your company better than anyone."
|